Exam AWS Certified Solutions Architect - Associate SAA-C03 topic 1 question 789 discussion

Option D... This is preventive control of Control Tower where we use SCP to disallow actions that lead to policy violation.

proactive controls pls see links for both * in inline policy: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/controltower/latest/userguide/iam-rules.html#ct-iam-pr-1-description and for ec2 public IP: https://docs.aws.amazon.com/controltower/latest/userguide/ec2-rules.html#ct-ec2-pr-9-description

Proactive controls check whether resources are compliant with your company policies and objectives, before the resources are provisioned in your accounts. If the resources are out of compliance, they are not provisioned. Proactive controls monitor resources that would be deployed in your accounts by means of AWS CloudFormation templates. For those who are familiar with AWS: In AWS Control Tower preventive controls are implemented with Service Control Policies (SCPs). Detective controls are implemented with AWS Config rules. Proactive controls are implemented with AWS CloudFormation hooks.

A - Proactive controls are a feature of AWS Control Tower that prevent noncompliant resources from being deployed by validating configurations before deployment. B - Detective controls can't block deployment. C - If you must monitor to get it right, then something's already wrong before you notice that. D - SCPs can indeed block specific API calls for creating IAM resources with "*" or EC2 instances with public IPs, but can't make the most of AWS CloudFormation stacks. Plus, SCPs apply at the account level and might inadvertently restrict legitimate use cases. Not ideal enough is what I'm saying.

Prevent AWS CloudFormation from deploying IAM resources and EC2 instances based on specific use cases = Control Tower Proactive controls. "Proactive controls are security controls that are designed to prevent the creation of noncompliant resources. For example (...), through AWS CloudFormation, the proactive control can prevent the creation of update of any S3 bucket that has public access enabled." https://docs.aws.amazon.com/prescriptive-guidance/latest/aws-security-controls/proactive-controls.html

this is A

Is D, the best way to prevent this actions, is deploying SCPs

It is D. You want to prevent the events from happening. Proactive controls check whether resources are compliant with your company policies and objectives, before the resources are provisioned in your accounts. Detective controls detect specific events when they occur and log the action in CloudTrail. Preventive controls prevent actions from occurring. Preventive controls are implemented with SCPs. Detective controls are implemented with AWS Config rules. Proactive controls are implemented with AWS CloudFormation hooks. https://docs.aws.amazon.com/controltower/latest/userguide/how-control-tower-works.html#how-controls-work

Proactive controls are implemented using AWS CloudFormation hooks within AWS Control Tower. They operate before resources are deployed to determine compliance with activated controls. SCPs are part of AWS Organizations and are used to manage permissions. vs Define specific purposes for implementing controls.https://docs.aws.amazon.com/controltower/latest/userguide/proactive-controls.html

A would provide a proactive solution, also I'm not sure if SCP are made for granular details like creation of EC2 instances with public IP addresses or IAM resources with certain inline policies.

Option D