Exam Certified Sharing and Visibility Architect topic 1 question 23 discussion

I went with C (disable using hierarchies & use critera-based sharing) because "these proposals should not be visble to anyone in the sales group other than the owner and the strategic team." Disabling the heirarchy access will ensure managers and users higher in the role heirarchy will not gain access. Because some propsals are "confidential", this must mean there is some level of criteria on the propsal that marks it as confidentials. As for non-confidential proposals retaining visibility, you could use a criteria based sharing rule (for non-cofidential) and share with a public group that has "Grant Access Using Hierarchies" enabled. You would all of the managers to the public group. May not be 100% precise if the role set up is all over the place, but assuming a normal sales rep > manager hierarchy, you can meet both sides of the requirements.

D. Disable Grant Access Using Hierarchies and set an Owner-Based Sharing rule for Strategic Deals team. Here’s why: Disable Grant Access Using Hierarchies: This ensures that the visibility of the Proposals is not automatically extended to users higher up in the role hierarchy, which is crucial for maintaining confidentiality. Owner-Based Sharing Rule: This allows you to create a sharing rule that grants access to the Strategic Proposals team based on the ownership of the Proposal. This way, only the owner and the Strategic Proposals team will have access to these confidential Proposals

Should it be D, as it needs to be combined with an owner-based?

The closest response is C for me. It's right but it's incomplete as all manager will lose visibility on Proposals.

WIll be B

For C : agreed to 2nd part for criterion based to identify "some" proposals we need criterion based sharing rules. But If we disable grant access using role hierarchy, how would it cater to the requirement which says "proposals are accesible to Account owners AND THIER MANAGERS"?